![]() Here's a simplified phrase-by-phrase comparison. You'll find that McCartney's tune runs largely parallel to that of "The Saints", as do the chords. It might take a couple of shots to get it right and that's mainly because the syncopation of the Beatles song is more pronounced. Singing "The Saints" while you're listening to "I Saw Her Standing There" is good way to compare them. I think "I Saw Her Standing There" was based unconsciously on "When The Saints Go Marching In". Who doesn't know "I Saw Her Standing There" or "When The Saints Go Marching In"? The Beatles performed the Bill Haley version of "The Saints" in their live set and recorded the song as backup band to Tony Sheridan. Subsequent articles, on both songs, will present the musical detail in all its glory. I've minimised the technical language to make this article more accessible. First, "The Saints Go Marching In" as the source of "I Saw Her Standing There", and second the Ray Charles' version of "Georgia" as the mythic dream song that inspired McCartney's "Yesterday". I'm going to present sources for two - mostly - McCartney songs. Naturally enough, some slip through the cracks. and you've written a Bob Dylan classic." (McCartney in: Coleman, 1996: 6) The great danger with writing is that you write someone else's song without realizing. The extreme case of this borrowing process is to recompose a complete song. A favorite case of mine is "Please Please Me" which is a patchwork quilt of style elements. ![]() Every Beatles' song is constructed largely out of style components, and thus borrows from other songs, as all songs must. It's hard to imagine what a completely original song might sound like, since the whole concept of style is based on the sharing of common style components. "Georgia On My Mind" (Hoagy Carmichael, 1929)įacing the songwriter's nightmare. " Just an old sweet song, keeps Georgia on my mind" For the latter - the song for which sources composer Paul McCartney himself sought in vain for a whole month - Hammond points at Ray Charles version of that other old sweet song: "Georgia On My Mind". As the masterprint of the former, he unearths "When The Saints (Go Marching In)". In some special cases, they even - unconsciously - made new songs out of some older ones, as Ian Hammond here shows for the McCartney compositions "I Saw Her Standing There" and "Yesterday". ![]() Even in their most innovative compositions the Beatles too were using the style components of the songs they had heard and loved. One Switch ($4.99) - One Switch is a Mac menu bar app that adds various switches to the Mac's menu bar.In search of the sources of "I Saw Her Standing There" and "Yesterday"Įvery writer of rock music, one way or the other, is reworking the lines of earlier songs. Subscribe to the MacRumors YouTube channel for more videos. Edit information under the Details, Artwork, Lyrics, Options, Sorting, and File tabs if you need to. Click Edit Items if you're editing more than one song. Right- or Control-click on a song or album. Open Music from your Dock or Applications folder. How to get song and album info in the Music app for Mac. For an in-depth look at Bartender 2, read use Bartender to supercharge your Mac's menu bar. It basically provides a second menu bar for when your Mac's menu bar starts to feel crowded. If you start accumulating menu-bar apps, you'll need an app to keep them organized. The app includes over 2.6 Million locations worldwide and provides real-time data with forecasting reports. You can easily integrate the app with your Mac’s menu bar and can customize it as per your requirements. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |